Quick Answer Under California Family Code section 3044, if a court finds that a person seeking custody committed domestic violence within the previous five years, the law presumes that giving that person sole or joint custody, legal or physical, is harmful to the child. The violence can have been against the other parent, the child, the child’s siblings, or certain other people such as a current partner. The presumption can be overcome, but only if that person proves that custody with them is in the child’s best interest and the judge weighs a list of factors, such as completing a batterer’s treatment program and following any restraining order. The usual preference for frequent contact with both parents cannot be used to overcome it.
If you are in danger now, call 911. The National Domestic Violence Hotline is free and confidential at 1-800-799-7233.
Last reviewed: November 22, 2026. Based on California Family Code section 3044 and the Judicial Council information sheet “Domestic Violence and Child Custody”. Custody decisions depend on the facts of each case.
In This Guide
- What the presumption says
- When it applies
- What counts as domestic violence here
- How the presumption can be overcome
- What cannot be used
- Visitation
- What the judge must do
- Practical points for each parent
- Frequently asked questions
What the Presumption Says
In most custody cases the judge starts from a neutral position and decides what is in the child’s best interest. Section 3044 changes the starting point. Once the court finds that a person seeking custody has committed domestic violence within the previous five years, there is a rebuttable presumption that an award of sole or joint physical or legal custody to that person is detrimental to the best interest of the child.
- It covers both kinds of custody. Legal custody is the right to make decisions about the child’s health, education and welfare. Physical custody is where the child lives.
- It covers joint custody as well as sole custody.
- “Rebuttable” means it can be overcome by evidence, on the standard of a preponderance of the evidence.
- It applies to non-parents too, if a non-parent is asking for custody.
When It Applies
The presumption applies when, within the last five years, the person seeking custody:
- was convicted of a domestic violence crime, after a trial or a guilty or no contest plea, or
- was found by a judge to have committed domestic violence, for example where a restraining order was granted after a hearing with testimony and evidence.
The finding can come from any court, not only the court deciding custody. The violence must have been against one of these people:
- the other party seeking custody
- the child or the child’s siblings
- certain other people connected to the person, which the Judicial Council’s information sheet describes as their current spouse or dating partner, or their own parent
A temporary restraining order granted without a hearing is not the same as a finding after evidence. Whether a particular order counts as a finding can be argued, so ask a self-help center or lawyer about your own order.
What Counts as Domestic Violence Here
Section 3044 has its own definition. A person has “perpetrated domestic violence” when the court finds that they:
- intentionally or recklessly caused or attempted to cause bodily injury, or sexual assault
- placed a person in reasonable fear of imminent serious bodily injury, or
- engaged in behavior for which a protective order could be issued under Family Code section 6320, such as threatening, striking, harassing, destroying personal property or disturbing the peace of another
Physical injury is therefore not required. See what counts as domestic violence in California.
How the Presumption Can Be Overcome
The person found to have committed domestic violence has the burden. The court must find both of the following.
First, best interest. That person has shown that giving them sole or joint custody is in the child’s best interest under Family Code sections 3011 and 3020.
Second, the additional factors. On balance, these factors support the Legislature’s findings in section 3020 about children’s health, safety and welfare:
| Factor | What the judge looks at |
|---|---|
| Batterer’s treatment | Whether the person has successfully completed a batterer’s treatment program that meets the Penal Code criteria. The information sheet describes this as a one-year program. |
| Alcohol or drug counseling | Whether it was completed, if the court finds counseling appropriate |
| Parenting class | Whether it was completed, if the court finds a class appropriate |
| Probation or parole | Whether the person is on probation or parole and has complied with its terms |
| Restraining orders | Whether the person is restrained by a protective or restraining order and has complied with it |
| Further violence | Whether the person has committed any further acts of domestic violence |
| Firearms | Whether a court has determined that the person has a firearm or ammunition in violation of the law |
No single factor decides the outcome, and completing a class does not automatically overcome the presumption. The judge weighs them together.
What Cannot Be Used
- The preference for contact with both parents. California law generally favors frequent and continuing contact with both parents. Section 3044 says that preference may not be used to rebut the presumption, in whole or in part.
- An evaluator’s opinion alone. A court may not base a domestic violence finding solely on the conclusions of a child custody evaluator or the recommendation of Family Court Services staff. It must consider any relevant, admissible evidence the parties submit. The judge must apply the factors even if a court professional recommends something different.
Visitation
Section 3044 is about custody. It does not by itself stop a parent from having visitation, which is also called parenting time. When there has been domestic violence, a judge deciding visitation looks at the safety of the child and the other parent, and can add conditions such as:
- supervised visits. See supervised visitation in California.
- exchanges at a neutral or public place, or through a third person
- no overnight visits for a period
- completion of a program before visits expand
Any visitation order has to be consistent with the terms of a restraining order that is in effect.
What the Judge Must Do
- Tell the parties about the law. In a custody or restraining order case where a party alleges domestic violence, the court must inform the parties about section 3044 and give them a copy before any custody mediation.
- Decide whether the section applies first. In a hearing or trial where custody is sought and domestic violence is alleged, the court must determine whether section 3044 applies before making a custody order. If more time is needed, the court can make a temporary custody order for a reasonable period.
- Give reasons. If the court decides the presumption has been overcome, it must state its reasons in writing or on the record, addressing the best interest showing and each of the factors.
If there has been domestic violence, tell the mediator. You can ask to meet with the mediator separately from the other parent. See child custody mediation in California.
Practical Points for Each Parent
If the other parent abused you:
- Raise the domestic violence in your custody papers. The judge cannot apply the presumption to facts they do not know about.
- Bring certified copies of any restraining order after hearing or criminal conviction, with the dates.
- If there is no earlier finding, you can ask the custody judge to make one, with your testimony and other evidence.
- Ask for the safety conditions you need in any visitation order.
- You can request a restraining order and custody orders in the same case. See how to get a restraining order in California.
If a finding has been made against you:
- Follow every term of any restraining order and of probation or parole.
- Complete the programs the court ordered and keep the certificates.
- Do not rely on the argument that children need both parents. The statute rules it out for this purpose.
- Be prepared to show, with specifics, why custody with you is in the child’s best interest now.
- Get legal advice. The consequences are significant and the rules are detailed.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is Family Code 3044?
It is a California law that presumes it is harmful to a child to give sole or joint custody to a person the court finds has committed domestic violence within the previous five years. The presumption can be overcome with evidence.
Can a parent with a domestic violence finding get custody?
Only if they overcome the presumption. They must prove that custody with them is in the child’s best interest, and the judge must weigh factors such as completing a batterer’s treatment program, obeying restraining orders and committing no further violence.
Does a restraining order trigger the 3044 presumption?
A restraining order granted after a hearing where the judge found domestic violence can trigger it. A criminal domestic violence conviction within the last five years also does.
How long does the presumption last?
It applies when the domestic violence was committed within the previous five years. After that the presumption itself no longer applies, but a judge can still consider a history of abuse when deciding the child’s best interest.
Can the abusive parent still have visitation?
Possibly. Section 3044 deals with custody, not visitation. A judge can order visitation with safety conditions, such as supervised visits or exchanges in a neutral place.
Does the violence have to be against the child?
No. It can be against the other parent, the child, the child’s siblings, or certain other people such as the person’s current spouse or dating partner.
Can a parent argue that children need both parents to overcome the presumption?
No. The statute says the preference for frequent and continuing contact with both parents may not be used to rebut the presumption, in whole or in part.
Does joint custody count?
Yes. The presumption applies to sole or joint custody, and to both legal and physical custody.
Bottom Line
A domestic violence finding within the last five years shifts the custody case against the person who committed it, and that person has to prove why custody with them is still in the child’s best interest. Make sure the judge knows about any finding or conviction, and bring the documents that show it.
Legal Sources
- California Family Code section 3044 (presumption against custody for a person who perpetrated domestic violence)
- California Family Code sections 3011 and 3020 (best interest of the child and legislative findings) and section 6320 (conduct that can be restrained)
- Judicial Council of California: Domestic Violence and Child Custody information sheet
Related Articles
- Best Interest of the Child
- What Counts as Domestic Violence in California
- How to Get a Restraining Order in California
- Supervised Visitation in California
- Child Custody Mediation in California
- Request for Order (FL-300)
Disclaimer: This article is general information, not legal advice. It was prepared by the site’s editorial team and was not written or reviewed by an attorney. This website is not a law firm. For help with your situation, contact your court’s self-help center, a domestic violence advocate or a licensed California attorney.